Your Local Epidemiologist

Share this post

Moderna booster works!

yourlocalepidemiologist.substack.com

Moderna booster works!

Katelyn Jetelina
May 11, 2021
24
2
Share
Share this post

Moderna booster works!

yourlocalepidemiologist.substack.com

We got the first round of results from the Moderna booster trial (here is the study and here is the press release).

Booster shots

A few months ago, Moderna started its Phase II trial with booster shots designed against the two similar variants of concern: B1.351 (S. Africa) and P.1 (Brazil). Specifically, they are testing three booster shot strategies:

  1. mRNA-1273.351: I’ll call this 351. This is basically a vaccine that includes instructions made JUST for the S protein found in the B.1.351 variant. This is called a monovalent vaccine- it’s designed to immunize against a single antigen.

  2. mRNA-1273.211: I’ll call this 211. This is a mixed vaccine: 50% with the original vaccine and 50% with 351 booster. This is called a polyvalent vaccine-it’s designed to immunize against two or more strains

  3. mRNA-1273: I’ll call this 1273. This is just a smaller dose (half actually) of the original vaccine that we already got.

This update is on the effectiveness and safety of 351 booster compared to the 1273 booster.

This was a “rollover” study, which means people in the original Phase III Moderna trial were invited to participate in the booster trial. If someone had at least 6 months of follow-up time since their original two-dose series and voiced interest, they were either given 351 or 1273. There were 20 people in each group.

Safety

351 had less side effects:

  • 351: fatigue (37%), headache (37%), muscle pain (32%), fever (0%)

  • 1273: fatigue (70%), headache (55%), joint pain (50%), muscle pain (45%), fever (15%)  

Effectiveness

351 also worked better

  • 351: Before the booster, variants had a 7.7 fold decrease in antibody neutralization. This is not surprising, as we know these variants are concerning. After the booster, though, there was a 2.6 fold decrease in neutralization. Which is great!

  • 1273: Before the booster, variants had a 7.3-fold decrease in antibody neutralization. After this booster, there was a 5.3 fold decrease in neutralization. This is better, but not as good as 351.

We’re waiting on more results to see how well 211 works.

We’ll probably have a booster by the end of the year. And probably annually for at least a few years until we get transmission down, so mutations slow down.

By the way, we just got word of the first animal trial on a flu/COVID19 combo vaccine by Novavax. So, ideally and eventually we would only need one shot a year.

Love, YLE

24
2
Share
Share this post

Moderna booster works!

yourlocalepidemiologist.substack.com
2 Comments
John Elliott
May 11, 2021Liked by Katelyn Jetelina

Is the expectation that a booster will only be effective if the original vaccine was from the same manufacturer or at least mRNA vs adenovirus?

Expand full comment
Reply
1 reply by Katelyn Jetelina
1 more comment…
Top
New
Community

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2023 Your Local Epidemiologist
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start WritingGet the app
Substack is the home for great writing