Abortion pills: An option not talked about
Public health touches all aspects of our lives, not just during a pandemic. Thanks to your feedback, this newsletter will continue with COVID updates and address other public health topics, too. To choose what topics land in your inbox, click HERE.
Today, the Supreme Court is set to rule in the medication abortion case. The legal, medical, and public health implications of this case are huge.
But regardless of what they rule, a really important piece of the story has gotten little attention the past few weeks: even if mifepristone is severely restricted, we have another option.
The other option
For a medication abortion in the U.S., patients are given two pills: mifepristone (“mife”) followed by misoprostol (“miso”).
The legal cases have focused solely on the first medication: mife. This is because mife was specifically approved by the FDA in 2000 for abortions, to be used followed by miso.
Miso, on the other hand, was approved in 1988 for the treatment of . . . stomach ulcers. It was given a warning label that if taken while pregnant, it would induce a miscarriage.
Miso has the most interesting history. Feminists in Brazil in the late 1980s noticed the warning label. Given no legal access to abortion in Brazil, they started taking it and spreading the word that miso could be used as a safe and effective means of abortion. And it was something you could buy at any local pharmacy. This self-use then led to clinical trials, where it was legitimized and moved to clinical use.
In the decades since, miso has been used off-label for medication abortion, induce labor, prevent postpartum hemorrhage, and more. It’s really an amazing drug.
In fact, much of the world relies on miso-only abortions where mife is less accessible.
Why isn’t miso only routinely used in the U.S.?
Clinical consensus has held that the combined regimen (mife+miso) is more effective at ending a pregnancy than miso only. This is primarily based on pooled data across a wide range of studies that included a wide range of ways people can use the medication: i.e., different dosages, different routes of administration, and different intervals between doses.
But if we look at the studies that report on a specific regimen (3+ doses of 800ug miso taken every three hours), miso only may be more effective than commonly thought. Across eight study groups that looked at 3+ doses of miso only, upwards of 90% had a complete abortion (compared to ~95% expected for the combined mife+miso regimen).
Miso only for abortion is also safe: only 0.7% of ~12,000 miso only users from a 2019 meta-analysis had a blood transfusion or were hospitalized for miso only abortion-related reasons.
As one journalist recently put it:
“It turns out our narrative has been backward. Biologically speaking, mife is the sidekick, and miso the superhero. Mife is the opening act while its counterpart carries the show.”
Restricting access to mife is epidemiologically baseless given 23-years of robust safety and effectiveness data. Yet, even with constrained choice, this does not mean that all medication abortion is off the table. People will still have access to a safe and effective method of medication abortion care: miso only. Let’s hope it doesn’t come to this.
YLE and HM
In case you missed previous posts:
Self-managed abortion with pills: Medically safe, legally risky
Heidi Moseson, PhD, is a reproductive epidemiologist and scientist at Ibis Reproductive Health. She studies abortion access in the U.S. with a particular focus on self-managed abortion with medications.
“Your Local Epidemiologist (YLE)” is written by Dr. Katelyn Jetelina, MPH PhD—an epidemiologist, data scientist, wife, and mom of two little girls. During the day she works at a nonpartisan health policy think tank and is a senior scientific consultant to a number of organizations, including the CDC. At night she writes this newsletter. Her main goal is to “translate” the ever-evolving public health science so that people will be well equipped to make evidence-based decisions. This newsletter is free thanks to the generous support of fellow YLE community members. To support this effort, subscribe below:
As an abortion provider and as a nurse-midwife I am very familiar with both medications and their use and efficacy. However, you missed a critical point: use of Mife followed by Miso is more comfortable and a kinder means by which to terminate a pregnancy. Three plus doses of Miso causes intense cramping for longer periods to get the end result. Not allowing Mife is pouring salt into the wounds of women who struggle when making the choice they feel is best for them. Imagine your rectum being in severe spasm for several hours: that’s what multiple Miso doses would be comparable to.
So this is the awful part. Miso works. So does methotrexate. But both can make you really sick. Vomiting and diarrhea for hours. (Re: miso at the dose needed when mife is not included)
The thing about mife, if I were to take it, non pregnant, I would likely feel nothing. It’s safer than Tylenol. So the question is… why are we taking away a safe medication with few side effects, and replacing them with meds that make people feel really awful?